Used these on a tour around Scotland and bought them specifically for the trip. I'm already a fan of Garibaldi gloves as I have their Urbe tan gloves- which are pretty much my go to gloves.
Needless to say, there was some pretty wet weather in Scotland- especially over Bealach na Bà and around the Applecross peninsula up to Gairloch. Stopped a few times for photo's and normally if gloves leak, the inside comes out and are a pain to get back on- this didn't happen with the Campus gloves. My fingers weren't 'toasty' warm but then again, not tingling with the cold.
Overall, gloves did exactly what I bought them for.
Great service from Salt Flats Clothing with next day delivery.